Blog: Speculative Non-Buddhism

In 2011, I founded the blog Speculative Non-Buddhism. The blog is closely related to my recent critical work. Many of the themes that have become elements of that work were first developed on the blog. SNB has had the good fortune of featuring work by Tom Pepper, Matthias Steingass, Adam S. Miller, Shyam Dodge, Richard Payne, Patricia Ivan, April Resnick, Alan Seltzer, and Craig Neely.


The blog has had nearly half a million views. It has also has nearly 1000 subscribers and has stimulated over 6000 comments. Some of these comments are substantial pieces of writing themselves. The blog has been discussed in scholarly works, such as Jay Michaelson, Evolving Dharma: Meditation, Buddhism, and the Next Generation of Enlightenment (Berkeley: North Atlantic Books, 2014); Marcus Boon, Eric Cazdyn, and Timothy Morton, Nothing: Three Inquiries in Buddhism (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2015); the Swedish anthology, Mindfulness: Tradition, tolkning och tillämpning (“Mindfulness: Tradition, Interpretation, and Application”); in the online work of Richard Payne (Dean, Institute of Buddhist Studies, Berkeley); Scott A. Mitchell, Buddhism in America: Global Religion, Local Contexts (New York: Bloomsbury Academic, 2016); and in the recent collection of essays by Ronald E. Purser, David Forbes. Adam Burke, Handbook of Mindfulness: Culture, Context and Social Engagement (Basel: Springer Publishing, 2016).

Buddhism in America

Global Religion, Local Contexts

- See more at:

Buddhism in America

Global Religion, Local Contexts

- See more at:


In keeping with the nature of critique, the blog is as controversial as it is influential. Here is an intelligent assessment by blogger Richard Blumberg:


Glenn Wallis's Speculative Non-Buddhism site is, to my mind, the most strikingly original, penetrating, and provocative writing about Buddhism on the web. I suspect that very many of the people who participate in this Community will find his stuff either impenetrable or irritating, or both, and some will just hate it and feel that Wallis has them under attack.


But his analysis of x-buddhism rewards the effort it takes to understand it and leads, I think, to a productive re-examination of how the Buddha's teachings remain relevant to our lives and how to most productively cultivate the Buddha's path to construct those lives as good ones. (X-buddhism: for 'x', substitute "zen", "tibetan", "nichiren", "pure land", "secular", "thich nhat hahn", etc. You get the idea.) He is especially concerned about how x-buddhism, through its emphasis on lineage, distinctive meditative techniques, the teachings of particular individuals, and a pervasive desire to "fit in" - to show that Buddhism is compatible with modern science, modern philosophy, modern culture - all lead to vitiating the radically anti-establishment, anti-authoritarian, anti-dogmatic implications of the Buddha's message.


I hope you will visit the blog and see for yourself!

Quick Links





Incite Seminars has a beautiful new home!

The Bourse, 111 S. Independence Mall East, Suite 540, Philadelphia, PA 19106 (5th Street between Market and Chestnut Streets). Here's a map. 

Upcoming seminars:

  • "For Education: The College Classroom as Concrete Utopia."  With Glenn Wallis. October 24, 10am-2pm.
  • "Why Marx Matters." With Gabriel Rockhill. November 23, 10am-2pm.
  • "Revolutionary Pessimism: On Political Action Without Expectation." With Scott Ritner. December 7, 10am-2pm. (Link forthcoming)
  • "The Environmental Emergency and Capitalism." With Zach Walsh, Thurs., November 14, 5:30-9pm.
  • "What Did Jacques Lacan Say About...?" With Patricia Ghervisi. January 11, 10am-2pm (Link forthcoming)


My new book , A Critique of Western Buddhism: Ruins of the Buddhist Real, is out: Bloomsbury Academic. More info here, too. You can read the entire Preface here.


Recommend this page on: